Here's our comparison of FIFA 12 and PES 2012.
Graphics
FIFA is top of the (able when it comes to football visuals.
The player models, while not as eerily realistic as those in the full console
versions of the game, are recognizable versions of their real-life
counterparts. And, this being FIFA, all the team strips are accurate.
Not quite the spectacle you get with FIFA 12, but the
players and stadiums are impressive enough, though animations aren't as subtle
and varied as FIFA's. The various menus and stat screens are slightly friendlier
for novices than FIFA's.
Play Mode
For the full experience, play the career mode in which you
manage your team and play in the games. In addition, there's a new daily
challenge to test your skills every 24 hours, quick matches and penalty shootouts.
A limited but satisfying palette of play options.
This is where PES 2012 scores highly. The full experience
includes Exhibition mode, UEFA tournaments, league cup matches, me Super Challenge
(essentially a career mode} and various individual challenges - the Free Kick
Challenge being particularly good fun.
Controls
FIFA 12 is now the undisputed king of iOS footy games,
thanks to its straightforward yet comprehensive control options. Three buttons
control passing, shooting and sprinting, but then gesture controls can be used to
pull off the more advanced moves.
PES 2012 has three control options, but the two-button
setting is the winner, with players using a stick to move and two buttons for
passing and shooting. Other moves can be accessed through combinations of
presses, holds, button/stick combas and swipes.
Multiplayer
No online multiplayer still and there's no easy way for two
players to hook up for a quick match locally, either. But if you have two
iPhones and an iPad, you can play head to head using the iPhones as controllers
and the iPad as a screen, or hook the iPad up to a TV.
There's no proper online play here, but tike-minded footy
fans can at least use Bluetooth and Wi-Fi to go head-to-head. You can also
persuade friends online to try to beat your achievements in the match challenge
leaderboards and Free Kick Challenge.
Realism
Authenticity was always FIFAs strong hand, now that the gameplay
is world-class too, this is the most realistic footy sim available. Real
players, real team, real leagues, superb animation, solid commentary, an ecstatic
crowd… it's full of big-game atmosphere.
The Achilles' heel of PES. Konami has done its best to make
this an authentic experience, and in terms of graphics and gameplay it does a
decent job. But the relative scarcity of licensed player and teams, and the
outdated kits, dilutes the experience.
Verdict
FIFA 12
The best footy experience on iOS by a considerable margin, and a step-up from last year's offering.
PES 2012
A perfectly playable and enjoyable footy game with plenty of options, but it just doesn't have the style or substance of FIFA12.

